This is a Pile of Rags, Right ? Wrong. It’s a Home..... - Instablogs
This is a Pile of Rags, Right ? Wrong. It’s a Home.....
Michael C , Lyon: Dec 21 2008
Made Popular Dec 22 2008
France :

This is a Pile of Rags, Right ? Wrong. It’s a Home.....

Practical. You know he’s home when it’s all piled up like that, because he’s under it. And it’s all flat and sad when he goes elsewhere.

So he’s at home in this picture, as you can see.

He? A guy who’s been living on this street, not far from my place, for the last three weeks. It’s a very busy downtown thoroughfare, complete with trams every three minutes and a busy two-way road as well. Maybe he feels less alone with people around him.

I took this picture at five pm Paris time, yesterday. The temperature was around zero. Five hours later it was minus three.

(Fact. there are a hundred thousand people without housing in France,) French only, sorry.

Most people I know think this should not be happening in 2008 in one of the most highly-developed countries in the world. These people include;
My neighbour, a 22 year-old law student, and three other student neighbours in my small apartment block. Then there’s Christine, divorced and a fierce advocate of housing for all. François, a computer programmer, finds all this very sad. Hazel, Isabelle, Michel and Dominique are also shocked by the homeless figures here in France.

And so am I. You too, probably.

And I know many more good-thinking people like us. Dozens of them, in fact.

But our sense of outrage at seeing people in this life-threatening situation (hundreds of homeless people will die of cold in France this winter) is not all we have in common.

The other thing we have in common is that the neighbors, Christine, François, Hazel, Isabelle, Michel, Dominique and all the others, including myself, are single.

This means that we live alone. And we all live alone in apartments or houses of at least 100 square meters and two bedrooms minimum.

It may seem hard to believe, but one third of houses or apartments here in France are occupied by only one person, and the figures go up every year. ONE THIRD! That means that at the end of 2007 there were 8.4 million under-used apartments or houses.

In fact, there are as many apartments or houses occupied by one person as there are occupied by two people. And this automatically means, of course, that only one third of housing here is occupied by three or more people (entire families). French only, sorry.

Think about it. We have a hundred thousand people out on the street, and a third of the country’s housing is under-occupied. Without counting the two-occupant households with several bedrooms!!

Wow!

So let’s get back to me and my friends. Why do we live alone?

Well, my student neighbor (and doubtless the other students in my block too) HATES the idea of being cooped up in a small place, and she likes to have spare bedrooms for friends, so daddy pays her this big apartment, to keep his little girl happy. Christine is divorced-like-everyone-else, and now feels that her “independence” is essential, and she feels good doing what she wants, when she wants, without being hassled by a man.

François is anti-social (but a good friend) and will probably never hook up in his life if he’s not careful. Hazel and Isabelle are professional women who don’t have time for permanent men, but need space for their lavish dinner parties. Same thing for Michel and Dominique, who, as men, also like inviting buddies (me included) to drink a few beers and change the world when they feel like it. And the list goes on.....

Me? Oh, I’m no better than they are. I’m taking a break from living with a girlfriend. I need space for my home recording studio too and my god daughter comes to stay often, as well as my friends, amongst them women, who fly by for a day or two from Berlin or Bordeaux on their way somewhere else. They all need privacy, of course. Also, I have had this place for years, so the rent is cheap because it’s inflation-linked and hasn’t been hiked up by the landlord.

In other words, we all live comfortable lifestyles and do what we want, because we are free citizens and value our independence in this modern world. Gone are the days of drudgery when people married early and had 2.5 kids and a dog and a goldfish and a family car and stayed together forever. Times change, and values change too.

But, and this is the point, these changing values are one of the causes of homelessness.

That’s why, paradoxically, although our parents, and society in general, had less money than we do, there were less homeless people too, because there were many more families and housing was mostly occupied by families. In fact when I was a kid, we would call the few homeless people to be seen “tramps”, a politically VERY incorrect term in these days of mass homelessness.

All this means that it’s hard to have to admit that our wonderfully modernist and emancipated principles and strong social consciences are one thing, but our real lives betray them. I mean no, I am not going to give up my spare bedroom to get a homeless person off the street.

I know what you may be thinking.

However...

...Before you condemn me as callous and indifferent, ask yourself this question.

When was the last time YOU took a homeless person off the street?

I thought so, so I guess you understand as well as I do that it is almost impossible to reconcile our high-and-mighty principles with our earthly actions.

Housing problem? Homeless problem? Listen. Given the way we live in today’s society, there will NEVER be enough money to house the 100 000 or more no-fixed-abode victims in this country. Period.

We live in a world where people isolate themselves more and more, a world in which more and more people feel they “need their own space”. And the economics of this social phenomena quite simply do not permit the building of two-or-more bedroom houses for each of us.

That’s the bottom line, like it or not. So we may as well get used to it as best we can.

Hard world? Yes. Very. And it’s getting harder.

Ask the guy under the Pile of Rags......

Michael C

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Denis
Geneve, Switzerland
I guess we live in different countries, though only 70km South of you, peole are a bit more hospitable.
1 Stars
Oscar
Oaxaca, Mexico
It’s not uncommon...I live 32 km from the city where homeless people are ignored..It’s a ratrace, nobody has time or a desire to help..This simply walk over them (literally)..

In my town there are few, but they are always cared for by the community (offered small jobs, shelter, food, clothing.)
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Oscar
Oaxaca, Mexico
This is really sad...


Would you say people end up like this in France (it is difficult for me to try to compare with Mexico where 40% of the country are poverty stricken) found life just too difficult..too cruel, overwhelming....OR does France just not have proper social programs to help them.

OR are many homeless by choice..they gave up on life and the daily struggle?

I can’t imagine anyone choosing to live like this..I know you lived in the railroad (metro) area by WILL, but these temperatures and conditions as you have shown, seem unbareable to live by Choice..

Or is it a combination of all?
2 Stars
Denis
Geneve, Switzerland
Oscar, I may be able to add a bit of perspective. Many years ago, I lived and worked in Baja and Oaxaca, as a matter of fact I hold a Mexican passport, because LopezPortillo granted me citizenship (that will tell you how many years ago)

Now, I live in rural France; south of the city, where Michael resides; and, having been born in New York City, I am more than familiar with the urban scene.

First off, France has the best social welfare system in the world. If the man on Michael’s street is French, he is gets a minimum wage and free health care. He may not be French, however. There are many people in France, who are the ’sans papier’, those without papers. For them life is more difficult. Some people are trying to help them, the current French president wants to round them up and send them to their country of birth.

Weather conditions in Lyon are not too different from many parts of Mexico. When Michael writes that the temperature was close to zero, he means Celsius, which would be 32°F.

I think Michael’s article is more descriptive of what is in Michael’s nearest environment. In the rural areas doors are open to all, as it was in rural Mexico. As a matter of fact, I have not seen the key to our front door for more than ten years. Minds are more open, also.

In general, I’d say that myopia is the common condition of the average French urban resident, Michael included. They ’see’ in a strictly defined manner. If you ever get to visit a French city, you will notice that most of them are wearing eyeglasses. I always think they are hiding behind them.

Now, we do not know more about this person on Michael’s street, because it seems that Michael did not talk to him. Remember Michael is the gallant protector of young women on the number 16 bus, who gives out his phone number, in case they feel needy. I’d like to know what is behind the different behaviours.
(Global Perspectives)
2 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Hi Oscar!

France does have social programs in the form of reinsertion programmes for homeless people (help with work or jobs) homeless shelters etcetera.

Most of the homeless here, from my personal experience, having worked with them, are French people who, following divorce, job loss, house loss or a combination, just opt out.......

The rest are are of immigrant origin, who find it hard here.......

I know it’s difficult to imagine people WANTING to live like this, but the fact is tht many DO, at least for a time...

So, as you say, it’s a combination of it all....

Seeya!
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Denis, it’s evident that you don’t know France too well....let me enlighten you a little.

1. ”If the man on Michael’s street is French, he is gets a minimum wage and free health care”.

Right for the (although strict minimum) health care, but completely erroneous concerning a minimum wage. The ”minimum wage” here, the ”SMIC” (Minimum Interprofessional Growth Salary) is the minimum salary here, inflation-linked, and is only paid to those who WORK. For those with serious problems, and who are unemployed, there is the ”RMI” (Minimum Revenue of Insertion) which is substantially lower than than the SMIC, but RARELY AVAILABLE to homeless people, because it’s only paid, except in rare cases, to French residents.
The fact is that homeless people here HAVE VERY LITTLE RIGHT TO MONEY, although see my answer to Oscar’s comment.

2. ”The current French president wants to round them up and send them to their country of birth”

Half the truth, thus misleading. Sarkozy is only (and of course you may not agree with the policy) following up policies first developed under Mitterand (Socialist President) and a Socialist government. The idea being that it’s not just because you ARE here that you have the RIGHT to STAY here with public money.
The current French admisistration, and President, are NOT the originators of this policy.

3. ”The ’sans papier’, those without papers. For them life is more difficult.”

On the contrary, and, the majority of them living in Paris, they are rarely on the street. Many are in insalubrious lodgins or poor accomodation, but they are, in the VAST majority, part of the homeless. In fact, the lobbying in their favour has resulted in ways of trying to find solutions for them, including regularisint those who work, and a lot of them do, I’m glad to say.

4. ”In the rural areas doors are open to all. Minds are more open, also”

I’d rather read this than be blind. Roms and gypsies are almost systematically thrown out of rural towns and villages (unlike in cities), and homeless people are not at all welcomed. They are more likely to be viewed as passers-through who are looking for what they can steal, and are made to understand that they are not welcome.
There are very few homeless help programmes in the French countryside.

5. ”In general, I’d say that myopia is the common condition of the average French urban resident, Michael included. They ’see’ in a strictly defined manner.”

Apart from the ridiculous generalisation, you need to know that I have spent more of my over twenty years in France living in the countryside. Where on earth did you get any other idea?

And that is why I am able to comment on your rose-tinted-glasses view of the countryside. Also, if you are a country person, how come you can be so knowledgeable about French city-dwellers?

Finally Denis, and I have said this to you before, why do you only paint half the picture? Why do you present ”facts” that are not? WHY CAN’T YOU DO SOME RESEARCH BEFORE WRITING?

If you don’t know the answer, I do. It’s because you want to make people believe things the way you want them to be, and not how they are.

A little seriousness would not go amiss....
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Correction.

”but they are, in the VAST majority, part of the homeless.”

I meant to say, of course, that they are NOT part of the homeless.

Excuse me.
1 Stars
Denis
Geneve, Switzerland
Michael, Your enumerated response is laughable, an each point. I shall not respond to them.

Perhaps, if the person under the rags was a good looking young woman, you’d open your heart and hearth.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Of course you won’t respond to my corrections Denis. You won’t respond because you know you have nothing to say.

I am very sorry to have to read this sad comment, which, unfortunately, says much more about you as it does about me.

You are beginning to appear more and more like the intellectual fraud merchant you are......

At YOUR age?!!!
1 Stars
Denis
Geneve, Switzerland
Tsk, tsk, trying to insult. Micah, without calling you any derogatives, I’ll state what I have learned from your articles. You are a 54 year old male, who is incapable of maintaining a steady intimate relationship with a woman, who has a job, teaching English, that is usually the realm of vagabonds, you live in an apartment in a shitty part of town that serves well for cheap student housing. You are vapid, vain and naive. If you were not so pompous, you could be kind sweet. Please continue to write articles.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
”54”?
Correct

”Incapable of a steady relationship?
LOL”!!

”has a job, teaching English, that is usually the realm of vagabonds.”?
Correct. I work for myself. Translator and interpreter too.
I teach language, like your sons do, and I quote
”my two sons. One teaches English, for a French NGO, in Siem Reap, Cambodia and the other teaches Mandarin Chinese to South KoreansTsk”,
I’m sure they’ll appreciate......

”in a shitty part of town that serves well for cheap student housing”?
Incorrect. One of the most invested- in areas of the whole of the city. NOT a student dorm.

”You are vapid, vain and naive. If you were not so pompous, you could be kind sweet”?
To each his opinion, but I do NOT always want to be kind and sweet.

”Continue to write articles”?
VERY correct.

Is that ok? I answered your questions and interrogations.

Now maybe you could answer the interrogations I listed too...?

If you won’t answer questions, why ask them?

Thanks Denis.
1 Stars
Sad !!!
well, when you wrote about your experience as a homeless person, I told you that I don’t know about the statistics of homelessness in Jordan... I still don’t... but I have never seen a homeless person in Jordan. this may not mean that they don’t exist, but even if they did, there are not many cases of homelessness (at least relatively speaking). And I have to give part of the credit to the fact that family life in my part of the world is different than yours, as children don’t have to move out of the family house unless they work/study in a far away place, or when they get married. This definitely has its bad effects, but it has lots of good ones as well, and I think sparing room for others is one of those good effects.
1 Stars
Denis
Geneve, Switzerland
This is very good news. I was under the impression that conditions in Jordan were getting a bit tough, due to the large numbers of Iraqi refugees. Has Jordan managed to house them all?...impressive!
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Hi Denis,
actually the Iraqis who decided to come to Jordan are the rich Iraqis, the poorer ones are those who headed to Syria and other cheaper places, since Jordan is considered to be the most expensive Arab city, so we can say that they managed to house themselves...
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Hmmm,,sorry, Jordan is the most expensive Arab COUNTRY...not city, LOL.... sorry :D
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
You just came up with a relevent point here, one I alluded to in the post.

The family structure seems stonger in Jordan, hence more help for younger people.

It is common to see young French men on the street here......

....because of family disagreements.
1 Stars
Oscar
Oaxaca, Mexico
The family living arrangement in Jordan is very common here in Mexico (well, for 55% percent of Mexico..40-45% are poor)

Our children live with us most commonly until finishing college and marrying..Even after marrying it is common for the families to live together.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Ok,

I am getting thoroughly sick and tired of you Denis.

Your inherent addiction to fabricating the truth, and your falsely condescending (but oh so revealing of your being caught in the act) attitude towards those who question your propaganda is becoming, quite frankly, boring and embarassing.

So, here it is people, no holds barred, and I will send links to what I am claiming to anyone who needs them.

Denis, in his own words, is an American citizen, a Swiss citizen, and a Mexican passport holder.

Well well, what a very interesting phenomena we have here in the person of Denis!!

In his own words, he is considered a terrorist in two countries, but can also get people into the UN sessions in Geneva because of his contacts if you send him a copy of your passport (Euhh ok...?)

has many years of military combat experience but also runs a spirituality site calling for love and peace and spiritual understanding (Euhh ok...?) (oh, and for the ”ten minutes per day program” to help you find inner peace bit in more detail you have to ”join”. I hope this doesn’t mean ”pay”, but I’ll find out...and post it).

has been down the coast of South Africa in protest against racism, but is twisted enough to say that the jews invented the word ”terrorism” and that Jews propagate terrorism in the world (Euhh ok...?)

says we should all stop reading the mainstream media and its mediocre and manipulating and money-making earthly concerns, but that doesn’t stop him putting up stacks and stacks of links on his page to precisely those ”worthless” subjects in order to ”hide” his sales pitch for his illuminatory views, and, cherry on the cake, claims elsewhere that a man OWES IT TO HIMSELF to make money because without it he cannot fulfill himself (Euhh ok...?)

claims, falsely, that UN law permits the death penalty for war crimes perpetrators (and, when you want to see the details, says that the UN hides them in archives)

says his wife came up with a UN ”law” (whereas the UN has no mandate to create ”Laws”, and that no ONE SINGLE person writes UN resolutions)

says that there is something called the ”Geneva convention Law of Exceptions” to explain some theory or other. It doesn’t exist.

And...

goes to Lyon (where I live) to watch (free!! I go too!!) rehearsals by classical singers ”when I’m in France”

Gives (recent) lectures all over the world,

has recently visited........

and, whilst doing all this, he still finds the time to spend most of every day, AND I SAID MOST OF EVERY DAY on IB, since the beginning of November, because he joined the site to ”Shake things up a little around here”!!!

Decidedly, a VERY interesting personality.

A VERY busy man.

In fact, one worth knowing a lot more about......

I just LOVE a challenge........

Denis, can’t you just chill out and get a little real?

Thank you.

Thanks.
1 Stars
Denis
Geneve, Switzerland
Micah, I have a bunch of kittens looking for a good home. Do you think it possible for you to admit a little love into your life?
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Ah Denis, would love to have a kitten, except I don’t think a kitten would like to live in an apartment (although many people have them in apartments, I just don’t think it’s a healthy natural life for them).

Admit a little love? Sure, from you too, if it’s offered..........instead of game playing.

Going out, seeya!!
1 Stars
Denis
Geneve, Switzerland
You wish to learn more. I know google is the reference for your life. google ”denis jones”+”human rights”, get 840,000+/- hits. . . and for the past few years have been trying for a low profile. Save you some digging, re: kayaking down the coast of Africa - http://www.unhchr.ch/pdf/wcrnewsletter4_fr.pdf

Yes, my life has taken many apparently contradictory paths, which are only contradictory, to someone who has done nothing. To me, it has been a flow.
(Global Perspectives)
1 Stars
Shahwar K
kolkata, India
Umm...there are NO, I MEAN NOT A SINGLE homeless person here in India...!

this is because, the STREETS are HOMES to countless numbers here!

is that a pretty picture...I DONT THINK SO!

”We live in a world where people isolate themselves more and more, a world in which more and more people feel they “need their own space”. And the economics of this social phenomana quite simply do not permit the building of two-or-more bedroomed houses for each of us.”

so so TRUE!

Good Post!
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Very funnily put Butterfly!!!

Just as a point of info for me, who are India’s homeless?

I mean are they all Indian? Is there caste involved? Etcetera......

But yes, I’ve heard India has many homeless...

”No homeless in India because”...

Typical You LOL!!

Seeya!!
1 Stars
Michael C
Lyon, France
Oh, forgot to ask, LS,

concerning single-occupier dwellings, is that true in India too? (so so TRUE!)

Wow!

Fly Fly...
Add your Comment